John Pickering and Partners

Latest News

Sources of information and help

John Pickering and Partners
freephone 0800 854201
e-mail mail@johnpickering.co.uk

Benefits Agency enquiry line 0800 882200

DSS Freephone Advice line 0800 666555

Occupational and Environmental Diseases Association (OEDA) 0200 8360 8490

Health and Safety Executive

National Asthma Campaign

 

Questions to ask a solicitor

Ask some of these questions before you entrust your asthma claim to a solicitor

  • Is the person who will be doing your case a qualified solicitor and will he or she do it personally?
  • How much experience of lung disease cases does the solicitor have?
  • What proportion of the solicitor's caseload involves lung disease?
  • Has the solicitor taken such cases to court, and if so, how many?
  • Does the solicitor or do his colleagues also work for employers and insurers defending compensation claims brought by people like you with lung disease? This is allowed, but you might not prefer your case to be dealt with by a firm that does not also work for the other side.
  • How long does it take the solicitor to get cases to a conclusion in court? If it typically takes more than 2 years, then it can be done more quickly.
  • Are the solicitors accredited by reputable organizations, such as The Occupational and Environmental Diseases Association (OEDA), the Law Society's Personal Injury Panel, The Spinal Injuries Association, Headway, or Action for Victims of Medical Accidents (AVMA)?

Your employer may be big and powerful, but your employer will refer your case immediately to an insurance company. Nearly all cases are settled without a trial, but this does not mean that these cases are easy. You will have your case settled faster and for more money if your solicitor takes a grip on the case and starts a court action quickly. Some solicitors prefer not to start court actions because it means more effort for them. It is always easier to wait and see if the insurance company will make you an offer. This is not the best thing for you.

Once you have chosen a solicitor and your case is underway, ask some of these questions:

  • Has a court action been started?
  • When will a court action be started?
  • Has your solicitor obtained the written evidence your employers will rely on at court?
  • Has your solicitor obtained witness statements, which will support your case?
  • Has your solicitor worked out the value of your case?
  • Has the solicitor obtained from the court a date when your case will be tried?
  • If a date has not been obtained, ask when this will be done

Although the Courts themselves have recently taken much more control of the progress and timetables of court actions, you are better with a solicitor who will force the pace.

If you ask about progress, you should be told within a few days exactly what is happening in your case. If your telephone calls or letters are ignored, there is likely to be something wrong, and it is most likely that your solicitor has too much work already. If your questions are ignored or you cannot understand the answers you get, or if you are forever ringing or writing without getting a reply, you should think about getting another solicitor.

 

Conditional fee or "no win no fee" agreements

If the solicitor can obtain an opinion from an appropriate chest or occupational physician that your asthma is occupational, or you already have such an opinion or a decision by the Benefits Agency, you should at this point be offered a conditional fee or "no win no fee" agreement by the solicitor. From now on, you should not be asked for any more money by the solicitor, who assumes the risk of taking on your case. The agreement means that if you lose or have to abandon your case on legal advice, you pay nothing for work done from the time the agreement is made. If you win or settle your case, your solicitor gets all or nearly all the cost of bringing the court action from your opponents, not from you.

Under this agreement, the solicitor will pay for insurance cover of up to £100,000 to protect you from having to pay the other side's charges if you lose or have to abandon your case.

Under this agreement, the solicitor will pay the money to others, which has to be paid during the case; otherwise you would have to pay this.

Providing your case is won or settled, the solicitor gets paid by the other side for work he has done and money he has paid out on your behalf. You are not likely to be asked to pay anything at all, because if you win or settle your case, the other side will pay all or nearly all of your legal charges.

 

How Does the Court Calculate Compensation

All cases are different.

The aim of the Compensation is to put you in the same financial position as if you did not have Occupational Asthma.

If an offer is made to you, ask your solicitor to break it down into the headings listed below, so you can understand what the offer means.

Compensation for pain and suffering

If you have occupational asthma you are entitled to compensation for the symptoms you have and the disability they cause, which will take into account the risk of you getting worse as time goes by. People with asthma have a very wide range of disability, so there is a wide range of awards from about £10,000 to as much as £50,000 for very severe disability.

If you hear about awards much higher than this, it is because of other items that you can claim for.

Interest on compensation for pain and suffering

This is paid at 2% from the date the court papers starting the case are sent to your employer or the company you are claiming against. The sooner a court action is begun, the more interest you will get.

Loss of wages/salary

If you are dismissed or have to give up your job because of asthma, then you will be awarded the money you have lost up to the point your case is decided in court, and you will be awarded money for future loss of wages. You will be awarded interest on the wages you have lost, at 3.5% a year.

Future loss of wages or salary is likely to be the biggest part of the award for many asthma victims. If you have to change your job because you developed asthma at work, or if you cannot work at all because of your illness, you may be given a large sum for future loss of earnings. For example, a person aged 40 may be given this loss of wages, which is worked out on a yearly basis, for 18 years.

Even if your loss is not a permanent one, and you will in the future get back to the level of earnings you had before you developed asthma, you may not be able to do this for several years.

Loss of earning capacity

Someone with occupational asthma, even if they have very mild symptoms, is not an attractive employment prospect for a future employer. Most larger employers ask questions about your health before taking you on. You will be at a disadvantage on the labour market. If you cannot tolerate cold air or any type of dust or fume, then even if you do not have to do this sort of work now, you might have to do it in the future, and you will be entitled to compensation for this loss of earning capacity. How much compensation a Court will award you for this is very unpredictable. It will depend on your age, your employability in other jobs that your asthma does not prevent you from doing, and your ability to retrain. But a loss of earning capacity award is likely to be given to anyone who has developed occupational asthma and has left their job, lost their job, or might lose their job in the future.

Care

If you need to be looked after by family or friends, either now or in the future, compensation will be awarded for this, even if the care you receive is provided free of charge, as it usually is. This will only be relevant if you have severe asthma, or might have severe asthma in the future.

Medical expenses

You are entitled to the cost of private medical treatment, but you will need to lay out the money for this yourself, unless the company you are claiming from admits fault during the court action. If they admit fault, you can get a payment on account (an interim payment) in your court action, which is sometimes used to pay for medical treatment. You are also entitled to be compensated for prescription charges and traveling expenses involved in medical treatment.

Special equipment

Badly disabled people have to buy stair lifts, specially adapted accommodation and bathrooms, or ground floor accommodation. You may need to have accommodation close to the people who are going to look after you.

Loss of a pension

If you lose your job, and there was a pension attached to the job, you are entitled to be compensated for the pension you have actually lost.

Specialist lawyers

Avoid Claims handlers

It is better to have a solicitor and a barrister who has specialized in lung disease compensation claims than to sign up with the claims handlers who advertise on television and radio. Some of these claims handlers have had very negative press recently, for various reasons. You are better off going directly to a specialist solicitor.

Avoid Non-specialist lawyers

It is better for you to go to a solicitor who has specialized in lung disease compensation claims than to a high street solicitor who might have done your conveyancing or prepared your will. You have a much better chance of winning the case and having it done quickly if you go to a specialist.

What will a solicitor do?

This is what should happen if you go to a specialist solicitor. The solicitor will want to establish that you do have occupational asthma, and that there is an employer or manufacturer with the ability to compensate you for this. The solicitor will not know you have occupational asthma unless a chest physician or occupational physician has investigated you already. If this has not already happened, your solicitor will probably ask you to request your GP to refer you to a specialist hospital unit, or you might want to see a specialist doctor at your own expense. If the solicitor knows about occupational asthma, he will be able to tell you which is the nearest such unit. You might want to pay a chest physician privately for such investigations and an opinion, but this will not usually be necessary unless there is some real urgency to start a court action within days or weeks. It is not likely that any solicitor will pay for a medical opinion unless you have already been told by your doctors or the Benefits Agency that you have occupational asthma. Such a medical opinion is likely to cost about £500 if you have to pay for it.

 

The State Benefits System

If you are told by a doctor or suspect that you have asthma caused by work, you should apply for industrial injuries disablement benefit, using the blue form B1 100 B, "Industrial Injuries Disablement Benefit for a prescribed industrial disease." You can get this from any Benefits Agency office.

The Benefits Agency publishes brochures about occupational asthma and industrial diseases generally.

Benefits Agency enquiry line 0800 882200

Industrial injuries disablement benefit is not withheld because you may have too much income or savings. It is not a means-tested benefit. Doctors from the Medical Boarding Centre, who work for the Government, must examine you. They will also probably review your medical notes. If you are very ill, these doctors may examine you at home.

You have to show the Benefits Agency that you have worked with one or more of the substances that they accept do cause occupational asthma. Your employers may not admit this, and you may need to supply names of people you work or worked with to confirm what you say.

The Benefits Agency will pay industrial injuries disablement benefit for occupational asthma caused by 22 specified groups of substance, and a final group, z, which brings in "any other sensitizing agent inhaled at work." The Benefits Agency has therefore acknowledged that there are many causes of asthma at work, because it is not realistic to list them all.

The Benefits Agency lists these substances: -

  • Isocyanates
  • Platinum salts
  • Acid anhydride and amine hardening agents
  • Fumes arising from the use of rosin as a soldering flux
  • Proteolytic enzymes
  • Animals including insects and other arthropods of their larval forms used for the purposes of research, education, in laboratories, pest control, or fruit cultivation
  • Dusts arising from barley, oats, rye, wheat or maize, or meal or flour made from such grain
  • Antibiotics
  • Cimetidine
  • Wood dusts
  • Ispaghula
  • Castor bean dust
  • Ipecacuanha
  • Azodicarbonamide
  • Glutaraldehyde
  • Persulphate salts or henna arising from their use in the hairdressing trade
  • Crustaceans or fish or products arising from these in the food processing industry
  • Reactive dyes
  • Soya bean
  • Tea dust
  • Green coffee bean dust
  • Fumes from stainless steel welding
  • Any other sensitizing agent inhaled at work.

It is likely to take the Benefits Agency several months to decide whether you are entitled to this benefit, which is paid as a weekly pension, so the earlier you begin the process, the better for you.

See the section about The State Benefits System in our Asbestos Compensation Guide

 
More Articles...

 

Apil Accredited Practice

Has your asbestos solicitor told you you don’t have a case? Would you like a second opinion without obligation? 

Please ring freephone
0808 144 0956

 

E-mail your details now
and we'll contact you

*Name
Telephone
*E-mail
Address
Postcode

Brief description of enquiry

 

Download our Asbestos Compensation Brochure

If you are a solicitor who does not specialise in doing asbestos disease claims, please click here for further information, including details of our competitive referral fees.

Mesothelioma Advice

Clinical Negligence Claims